For most Tyler homeowners the right answer comes down to how long you plan to stay in the house and how much you want to spend up front. Architectural asphalt shingles cost less and do a good job for a couple of decades. Metal costs more on day one and can outlast two or three shingle roofs. Both handle East Texas weather well when they are installed correctly. Here is the comparison without the sales pitch.
Up-front cost
Metal roofing costs more than asphalt, and the gap is wide. Standing seam panels with concealed fasteners are at the top of the range; exposed-fastener screw-down panels are closer to premium shingles. Metal also takes more labor hours and specialized trim work, so the installation cost is higher too. Advantage installs both, and we quote them side by side so you can see the difference on your actual roof. Both can be paid through our financing options.
Lifespan in East Texas
Heat and humidity are what age roofs here. Asphalt shingles soften, lose granules and dry out through decades of summers. A quality architectural shingle installed with proper attic ventilation gives roughly 20 to 30 years in our climate; cheaper three-tab shingles give less. Metal panels are not bothered by the heat and will typically last 40 to 70 years depending on the metal, the coating and the fastener type. If you plan to stay in your Tyler home for the long haul, metal’s cost per year of service is competitive.
Hail
This is the question that matters most around here. Hail dents metal and bruises shingles. A dented metal panel still sheds water; a bruised shingle has a fractured mat and will fail early. On balance metal survives hail better, with two cautions. First, many insurers exclude cosmetic dents on metal roofs, so read your policy. Second, severe hail can crack a metal panel’s coating, and that needs attention to prevent rust. Class 4 impact-resistant shingles close some of the gap on the asphalt side.
Wind
Both can be rated for high winds. Shingles rely on a factory sealant strip that bonds in warm weather, plus correct nailing. Metal relies on the fastening pattern and clips. Both fail at the edges when installed poorly. On a well-installed roof of either type, wind is rarely the deciding factor in Tyler.
Heat and energy
Metal reflects more of the sun’s heat than a dark shingle, especially in lighter colors or with reflective coatings, which can lower attic temperatures. Shingles are available in cooler colors too, and an attic with proper ventilation and insulation closes much of the gap. Neither roof substitutes for a well-ventilated attic.
Noise
A metal roof installed over solid decking and underlayment, the way Advantage installs them on homes, is not noticeably louder in rain than a shingle roof. The “tin roof” sound comes from metal over open framing, as on barns and porches.
Appearance and resale
Architectural shingles are what most buyers in Tyler neighborhoods expect, and some HOAs restrict metal. Standing seam metal has become popular on farmhouse and modern styles and on rural properties around Lindale, Bullard and Whitehouse. A well-kept roof of either kind helps at resale; a roof near the end of its life hurts.
Repairs and maintenance
Shingle repairs are simple and any competent roofer can match them. Metal repairs are more specialized, and on screw-down panels the fasteners’ rubber washers age and need periodic replacement. Both need their penetrations, flashings and sealants checked every few years.
A quick decision guide
- Staying 10 years or less, budget-conscious: architectural shingles, Class 4 if hail is a worry.
- Staying 20 years or more, want to replace once: metal.
- Rural property with a simple roofline: metal is often the better value.
- Complex roofline with many valleys and dormers: shingles are easier and cheaper to detail well.
- HOA neighborhood: check the covenants before you fall in love with either.
Talk through it on your roof
Advantage Roofing Company has installed shingle and metal roofs across Tyler and East Texas since 2008. We are an Owens Corning Platinum Preferred contractor on the shingle side and install metal systems on homes and commercial buildings. The inspection and the estimates are free. Call (903) 939-3168 or schedule online.