Recoverable depreciation is the money your insurance company holds back from a roof claim until you actually replace the roof. On a replacement cost policy, the insurer first pays the depreciated value of your old roof, then releases the rest once the work is complete and invoiced. Homeowners in Tyler lose this money every year by not finishing the job, missing a deadline, or not sending the paperwork. Here is how it works and how to make sure you get it.
Two checks, not one
When an adjuster writes a roof claim, the estimate shows three numbers:
- Replacement cost value (RCV): what it costs to replace the roof today.
- Depreciation: a deduction for the roof’s age and wear.
- Actual cash value (ACV): the RCV minus depreciation.
The first payment is the ACV minus your deductible. The depreciation is “recoverable” if your policy is a replacement cost policy: once you replace the roof and submit the final invoice, the insurer pays the depreciation as a second check. If your policy is an actual cash value policy, the depreciation is not recoverable and the first check is the only check.
How depreciation is calculated
Insurers assign a useful life to the roof, often 20 to 30 years for asphalt shingles, and depreciate the roof’s value in proportion to its age. A 10-year-old roof on a 25-year life is depreciated 40 percent. Some adjusters also depreciate for condition. The percentage is printed on the loss statement; ask for it if it is not.
What triggers the release
- The replacement is completed.
- The roofer’s final invoice shows the work done at a cost equal to or above the RCV on the claim (or the actual cost, if lower).
- A certificate of completion, often with photos, is sent to the adjuster.
- Proof that the deductible was paid, if the insurer requests it. Texas law requires that you pay it.
Advantage sends this package to your insurer on every claim job in the Tyler area. The depreciation check typically arrives within a few weeks.
The deadline
Policies set a time limit to complete the repairs and claim the depreciation, commonly within a year of the date of loss, sometimes less. After a large hail event, with every roofer in East Texas booked, a year goes faster than it sounds. If you are getting close, ask your insurer in writing for an extension; most grant them when the delay is reasonable.
What if the roof costs less than the claim?
The insurer pays the lesser of the claim’s RCV or your actual cost. Choosing a cheaper shingle does not create a refund; it reduces the depreciation they release.
What if it costs more?
If the adjuster’s scope missed items, such as code-required drip edge, ice and water shield, extra decking, or a second slope, your roofer submits a supplement with documentation. Approved supplements are paid on top of the original claim, with their own depreciation released at completion.
Mortgage company endorsements
If you have a mortgage, claim checks above a certain amount are made out to you and your lender. The lender endorses them, sometimes in stages after their own inspection. Start that process the day you receive a check so it does not delay your roofer.
Mistakes that forfeit the money
- Keeping the first check and never replacing the roof.
- Letting the deadline pass.
- Hiring a contractor who leaves town before sending the completion paperwork.
- Doing a partial repair when the claim was written for a replacement, then invoicing less than expected.
- Accepting a contractor’s offer to “eat” the deductible, which is illegal and can jeopardize the whole claim.
Make sure you collect it
Advantage Roofing Company has handled storm claims in Tyler since 2008, from the first inspection through the depreciation release. If you have a claim in progress or a storm-damaged roof that needs one, call (903) 939-3168 or schedule a free inspection.