Architectural shingles are thicker, heavier, longer-lasting and better-looking than three-tab shingles, and they cost more. On nearly every Tyler home being reroofed today, they are the right choice, and they are what most insurers now expect to see on a replacement claim. Three-tab shingles still have a place on sheds, rental properties and tight budgets. Here is the real difference, beyond the price tag.
How each shingle is built
A three-tab shingle is a single flat layer of asphalt-coated fiberglass mat with granules on top, notched into three tabs so that a finished roof shows a uniform brick pattern. Every shingle is the same size and shape.
An architectural shingle, also called dimensional or laminated, is two or more layers bonded together. The top layer is cut in a random pattern and laminated over a solid base, which creates shadow lines and the look of thicker wood shakes. The result is a heavier shingle with more asphalt and a stronger mat.
Durability in East Texas heat
The extra asphalt is what matters here. Tyler summers bake the oils out of a shingle; a thin three-tab dries out, curls at the corners and loses its granules years before a laminated shingle does. Expect roughly 12 to 18 years from three-tab in our climate, and 20 to 30 from a good architectural line over a ventilated attic. The warranty terms track that difference: three-tab shingles typically carry 20 to 25 year limited warranties, architectural shingles limited lifetime warranties.
Wind
Three-tab shingles are usually rated for 60 to 70 mile-per-hour winds; many architectural lines are rated for 110 to 130 with the manufacturer’s nailing pattern, because the laminated construction gives the sealant strip more to hold. Tyler sees straight-line wind from spring storms every year, and lifted three-tab shingles are one of the most common repairs we make.
Hail
Standard architectural shingles resist hail better than three-tab because of their thickness, but neither is impact rated. If hail is your concern, the step up is a Class 4 impact-resistant architectural shingle, which may also earn an insurance discount in Texas.
Appearance
Three-tab gives a flat, uniform look. Architectural shingles have depth and varied shadow, and they come in blended colors that hide dirt and wear. Most Tyler neighborhoods built since the 1990s are entirely architectural, and a three-tab roof on an architectural street looks like what it is: the budget option.
Installation
Architectural shingles are faster to lay because there are no tabs to align course to course, and the random pattern hides small deviations. They are also more forgiving of a slightly uneven deck. The labor cost per square is similar.
Cost
Architectural shingles cost more per square than three-tab, and because they are heavier, slightly more to haul and handle. Over the roof’s life, though, the longer service interval usually makes them cheaper per year. Advantage quotes both when a customer asks, and both can be paid through financing.
Where three-tab still makes sense
- Detached garages, sheds and outbuildings.
- Matching an existing three-tab roof on a small repair or addition.
- A property you plan to sell soon where the roof only has to be sound.
- Low-slope sections where the manufacturer allows it and appearance does not matter.
Which lines Advantage installs
We install architectural shingles from Owens Corning, GAF and CertainTeed, with Class 4 options from each, and three-tab where the job calls for it. As an Owens Corning Platinum Preferred contractor, we can offer extended warranties on their systems that are not available from most installers.
See them side by side
The easiest way to decide is to see sample boards on your own house in daylight. Advantage Roofing Company provides free inspections and estimates in Tyler and East Texas, and we bring samples. Call (903) 939-3168 or schedule online.