Owens Corning vs. GAF vs. CertainTeed: How Advantage Chooses Shingles

Advantage Roofing Company installs shingles from Owens Corning, GAF and CertainTeed, the three largest manufacturers in the country. All three make good roofs. The differences are in the details: how the shingle is built, which colors are offered, how the warranty programs work and which contractor certifications unlock them. Here is how we think about each when we quote a Tyler home.

What the three have in common

Each makes a fiberglass-mat asphalt shingle in three-tab, architectural and premium designer lines, with Class 4 impact-resistant options and high-wind ratings on the architectural lines. Each offers limited lifetime material warranties and enhanced system warranties through certified contractors. Each has a plant network that keeps the common lines stocked in East Texas. On a Tyler roof, the installation and the ventilation matter more than which of the three is on the wrapper. Within that, here are the distinctions.

Owens Corning

Known for weather resistance and durability. Their flagship architectural line, Duration, uses a reinforced fabric strip in the nail zone that the company calls SureNail, which gives the nails a wider, stronger target and contributes to a high wind rating. The Class 4 version is Duration FLEX. Colors are consistent and well suited to brick homes common in Tyler neighborhoods.

Advantage is an Owens Corning Platinum Preferred contractor, the top tier of their network. That status lets us offer their extended system warranties, which add non-prorated material coverage and manufacturer-backed workmanship coverage beyond the standard limited lifetime warranty. For many customers, that warranty is the deciding factor, and it is why Owens Corning is our most-installed brand.

GAF

Known for rugged, dependable performance and the largest market share in the country. Their Timberline HDZ architectural shingle has a wide nailing zone and a layer-bonding design that locks the laminated pieces together. The Class 4 line is Timberline AS II. GAF’s color range is broad, and their enhanced warranties are available through certified contractors, which Advantage is.

CertainTeed

Known for limitless customization and style options. Landmark is their architectural line, available in more colors and blends than most, with a wide nailing area. Their Class 4 options include Landmark ClimateFlex. CertainTeed’s premium designer lines, which imitate slate and shake, are a common choice when a homeowner wants a distinctive look on a visible roof.

How we choose for a given roof

  • Warranty priority: Owens Corning, because of the Platinum Preferred system warranty.
  • Hail priority: any of the three Class 4 lines; we match the color first and then the brand.
  • Color match to brick, stone or trim: CertainTeed’s range is the widest, Owens Corning’s blends suit red and brown brick especially well.
  • Insurance replacement with a discontinued color: whichever brand has the closest current match.
  • Budget: the standard architectural lines from all three are priced closely; the difference is usually in the warranty.

Matching an existing roof

On a repair, the brand question is settled by what is already on the roof. A replacement shingle from a different manufacturer will not match in size, exposure or color, and the patch will show. Shingle lines also get discontinued and colors drift between production runs, which is why we keep the manufacturer, line and color name of every roof we install in your file. If a discontinued shingle cannot be matched on a storm repair, that is grounds for a supplement to replace the whole slope, and insurers generally accept it when it is documented.

Warranty programs, briefly

All three brands offer a standard limited lifetime warranty on their architectural lines and an enhanced tier through certified contractors. The enhanced tiers differ in their non-prorated periods, in whether labor and tear-off are covered, and in how much workmanship coverage the manufacturer backs. We lay the three warranty sheets side by side on every estimate so the comparison is on paper, not in a sales pitch.

What does not matter much

Brand rivalry. A Timberline, a Duration and a Landmark installed the same way over the same ventilation will perform similarly in Tyler’s climate. What separates roofs that last 25 years from roofs that fail at 12 is nailing, flashing, starter, underlayment and attic airflow. That is the contractor’s work, not the manufacturer’s.

See the samples

The right way to choose is to hold sample boards against your brick in daylight and compare the warranty sheets side by side. Advantage brings samples to every free estimate in Tyler. Call (903) 939-3168 or schedule online.

Residential

If you're building a home or office, trust Advantage Roofing with your shingle roof installation

Commercial

If your flat roof is leaking, don't take time out of your busy schedule to attempt a DIY repair job.

Storm Damage

When your property has weathered a storm, you can count on Advantage Roofing Company!

Gallery

Take a moment to view our past projects.