When shingles blow off a roof that is only a few years old, the wind is rarely the cause. Architectural shingles are rated for 110 miles per hour and higher; a Tyler thunderstorm gust of 50 or 60 should not touch them. A roof that loses shingles in those conditions has an installation problem, and the pattern of what came off usually says which one. Here are the causes we find on East Texas roofs, and what to do about them.
High nails
The most common cause. Each shingle is nailed through a specific zone so the nail also catches the top edge of the shingle below, holding two courses with every nail. When nails are driven above that zone, often because a crew is working fast with nail guns, they hold only the top shingle, and the shingle below is held only by its sealant strip. In wind, that lower shingle lifts, creases and tears. High-nailed roofs shed shingles in horizontal bands rather than at random.
Too few nails or badly driven nails
Manufacturers specify four nails per shingle, six for the high-wind rating. Three-nail installations or nails driven at an angle, overdriven through the mat, or underdriven so they hold the shingle above it off the surface all reduce holding power. Overdriven nails are especially common with gun pressure set too high; the nail head cuts through the shingle and holds nothing.
Sealant that never bonded
The adhesive strip on each shingle needs sun and warmth to bond to the shingle below. Roofs installed in cool, cloudy weather, or in dusty conditions that coat the strip, may never seal properly. Unsealed shingles can be lifted by hand with little resistance. Crews installing in cool weather should hand-seal with roofing cement; many do not. This is why winter installations by careless crews lose shingles in the first spring storm.
Missing or wrong starter strip
The first course at the eave and the edges at the rakes take the most wind. A proper starter strip has its sealant at the outer edge to glue the first course down. Roofers who use cut-down field shingles with the sealant in the wrong place, or skip starter at the rakes, leave the edges to lift. Roofs that lose shingles along the eaves and rakes first usually have a starter problem.
No drip edge or lifted drip edge
Drip edge holds the edge of the roof down and keeps wind from getting under it. Missing drip edge at the rakes is a frequent find on cheap roofs.
Deck problems
Nails driven into gaps between decking boards, into rotten wood, or into decking too thin to hold them pull out under load. A roof-over on an uneven old roof also prevents shingles from sealing flat.
Wind during installation
Shingles laid on a windy day can be lifted before they seal, and some get creased during installation without anyone noticing. They fail at the first real storm.
How to tell what your roof has
Look at where the shingles came off. Edges and eaves point to starter and drip edge; bands across a slope point to high nails; random single shingles on a cool-weather install point to sealant. On the roof, lifting a shingle gently shows whether the sealant has bonded and where the nails sit. Advantage inspects roofs in Tyler for free and will document the cause with photos.
What should happen next
A roof that lost shingles because of installation defects is a workmanship warranty claim against the installer, if the installer is still in business and the warranty has not expired. That is the argument for a long workmanship warranty from a company with a local office. Advantage offers a lifetime workmanship warranty on qualifying installations, and our Tyler office at 16678 State Hwy 155 S has been here since 2008.
If the installer is gone, the question becomes whether the roof can be corrected, by re-nailing and hand-sealing, or whether the defects are widespread enough that a replacement is the only durable fix. We will tell you honestly which it is.
Have it looked at
If your roof has lost shingles more than once, the next storm will take more. Call Advantage Roofing Company at (903) 939-3168 or schedule a free inspection.