What Is Ice and Water Shield, and Do East Texas Roofs Need It?

Yes, although in Tyler the name undersells the reason. Ice and water shield is a self-adhering rubberized asphalt membrane that seals around nails and bonds to the deck, so water that gets under the shingles cannot reach the wood. Up north it stops ice dams. In East Texas it stops wind-driven rain in valleys, around chimneys and skylights, at every pipe and vent, and along eaves on low-slope sections, which is where our roofs leak. Advantage installs it at those locations on every replacement.

How it differs from underlayment

Standard underlayment, felt or synthetic, is water-resistant: it sheds water that runs across it, but every nail through it is a hole, and water that sits on it or is driven up under it finds the holes. Ice and water shield is a sticky membrane. Pressed onto the deck, it bonds permanently; when a nail goes through, the rubberized asphalt seals around the shank. Water cannot run under it, and it cannot leak at the fasteners. That makes it the right material wherever water concentrates or backs up.

Where it belongs on a Tyler roof

Valleys

Two slopes pour into a valley, and in a hard East Texas rain the water runs deep and fast. Wind pushes it sideways under the shingles. A strip of membrane the full length of each valley, under any valley metal, is the single most important leak prevention on a complex roof.

Around chimneys, skylights and walls

Flashing handles most of the water at these intersections. The membrane under and around the flashing catches what the flashing misses, including at the uphill side of a chimney where debris collects.

At every penetration

Pipe boots, vents, exhaust fans and satellite mounts. A square of membrane around each, under the flashing, protects against the boot’s eventual cracking.

Along the eaves

Required by code in cold climates to cover the area where ice dams form. In Tyler, eave coverage matters on low-slope roofs, where wind-driven rain backs up under the first courses, and on homes that have seen ice in past winters. We recommend it along eaves on low-pitch sections and consider it standard on roofs with a history of edge leaks.

Low-slope sections

Porch roofs and additions with minimal pitch are often covered entirely with membrane under the shingles, because shingles at low pitch do not shed water reliably on their own.

Full-deck coverage

Some homeowners choose to cover the entire deck with ice and water shield. It gives the maximum protection against wind-driven rain and is sometimes specified on very low-pitch roofs or by homeowners in exposed locations. The trade-offs are cost and the fact that a fully membraned deck is not vapor-permeable, which places more importance on attic ventilation. It is not necessary on most Tyler homes, and we will tell you if yours is an exception.

Why it matters for insurance claims

Many building codes require ice barrier at eaves and valleys on new shingle roofs, and when an insurance claim pays for a replacement, code-required membrane can be added to the scope as a code upgrade. A roofer who knows this includes it in the supplement; one who does not leaves it off and your roof goes without.

What to look for on an estimate

The estimate should name the product and state where it will be installed: valleys, penetrations, chimneys, eaves and low-slope areas at minimum. “Underlayment” alone does not mean ice and water shield. If the estimate does not mention it, ask; if the answer is that it is not needed in Texas, get another estimate.

The warranty connection

Manufacturers’ enhanced system warranties require their own ice and water product as a component. The Owens Corning system warranties Advantage can offer as a Platinum Preferred contractor are an example: the shield is part of what qualifies the roof.

Protect the places that leak first

Advantage Roofing Company has roofed Tyler and East Texas since 2008, and valleys and penetrations are where we see most leaks on roofs that others installed. Call (903) 939-3168 or schedule a free inspection.

Residential

If you're building a home or office, trust Advantage Roofing with your shingle roof installation

Commercial

If your flat roof is leaking, don't take time out of your busy schedule to attempt a DIY repair job.

Storm Damage

When your property has weathered a storm, you can count on Advantage Roofing Company!

Gallery

Take a moment to view our past projects.