Usually yes, when the roof is damaged by a sudden event the policy covers, such as hail, wind, a fallen tree or fire. Usually no, when the roof simply wore out, was neglected, or was already past its useful life. Between those two answers sits a lot of policy language, and that language decides whether a Tyler homeowner gets a new roof or a check that does not cover one.
Covered perils versus wear and tear
Homeowners insurance is built to pay for sudden, accidental damage. In East Texas that most often means hail and straight-line wind. It also covers damage from falling objects, like a pine limb through the decking, and from lightning or fire.
It does not cover a roof that is old, curling, balding or leaking because of age. It will not pay to fix a roof that was installed wrong. And if a covered storm damages a roof that was already failing, the adjuster will try to separate the storm damage from the pre-existing condition, which is why documented inspections before and after storms are so valuable.
The terms that change the payout
Replacement cost value (RCV)
An RCV policy pays what it costs to replace the roof with similar materials today, minus your deductible. Most policies pay this in two steps: an initial check for the depreciated value, then the held-back depreciation once the work is complete and invoiced.
Actual cash value (ACV)
An ACV policy pays the replacement cost minus depreciation for age and wear, and that depreciation is not recoverable. On a roof that is 15 years old, the ACV payment can be a fraction of what a new roof costs. Many Texas insurers have moved older roofs to ACV, sometimes without the homeowner noticing the change at renewal.
Roof payment schedules
Some policies include a schedule that reduces the payout by a set percentage per year of roof age, regardless of the roof’s actual condition. Check your declarations page for the words “roof surfacing payment schedule.”
Wind and hail deductibles
Texas policies commonly carry a separate wind and hail deductible calculated as a percentage of the dwelling coverage, often 1 to 2 percent, rather than a flat dollar amount. On a home insured for a few hundred thousand dollars, that deductible is thousands of dollars, and it comes out of the claim before you see anything.
Cosmetic damage exclusions
Some policies, especially on metal roofs, exclude cosmetic hail damage: dents that do not affect the roof’s ability to shed water. If you have a metal roof, read for a cosmetic damage endorsement before a storm, not after.
What makes a claim succeed
- An inspection and photo report soon after the storm.
- Evidence on the soft metals: dented vents, gutters and flashing establish hail size and direction.
- A clear storm date that matches weather records.
- A contractor’s scope of work that lists every damaged component.
- Your presence, or your roofer’s, at the adjuster’s inspection.
Advantage Roofing Company has handled storm claims in Tyler and East Texas since 2008. We document the roof, meet the adjuster, and make sure the scope reflects what is actually on the roof, including code-required items like drip edge and ice and water shield. We do not waive deductibles. Texas law prohibits it, and it is a sign of a contractor you should not hire.
When insurance will not pay
If the roof is worn out rather than storm damaged, the choices are repair, Shingle Rx rejuvenation for roofs with life left in them, or a replacement paid out of pocket or through financing. Our inspection is free either way, and we will tell you plainly which category your roof falls in.
Find out where your roof stands
If you are unsure whether your roof has claimable damage, or whether your policy would pay enough to replace it, start with a free inspection. Call Advantage Roofing in Tyler at (903) 939-3168 or schedule online.