Standing Seam vs. Screw-Down Metal Roofing: Which Is Right for an East Texas Home?

Standing seam metal roofing uses panels joined at raised seams with the fasteners hidden underneath; screw-down (exposed-fastener) metal roofing uses overlapping corrugated or ribbed panels screwed directly through the face. Standing seam costs more and lasts longer with less maintenance. Screw-down costs less and relies on thousands of rubber-washered screws that need attention over the years. Both are installed across Tyler and East Texas, and both can be the right choice. Here is how to tell which fits your home.

How each is built

Standing seam

Panels run from eave to ridge, typically 12 to 18 inches wide, with vertical legs on each edge. Clips fastened to the deck hold the panels; the legs of adjacent panels are snapped or mechanically seamed together over the clips. No fastener penetrates the panel surface, and the clips allow the metal to expand and contract with temperature without stressing the fasteners.

Screw-down

Panels, often 36 inches wide with ribs or corrugations, overlap at the edges and are screwed through the face into the decking or purlins on a grid, usually every couple of feet. Each screw has a neoprene washer that seals the hole.

Lifespan and maintenance

Standing seam panels, with a quality coating, commonly last 40 to 70 years with little more than periodic inspection of flashings and sealants. Screw-down panels last as long, but the washers do not. In Texas heat the neoprene dries and cracks, and the daily expansion and contraction of the metal works the screw holes larger. Within 10 to 20 years a screw-down roof needs its fasteners replaced with larger-diameter screws, and some holes need sealing. Skipping that maintenance is how screw-down roofs leak.

Cost

Standing seam is the more expensive system, in material, in labor and in the trim work at hips, valleys and penetrations. Screw-down is substantially cheaper and faster to install, which is why it covers most barns, shops and rural outbuildings in Smith County and a fair number of houses.

Hail and wind

Both dent in large hail; neither leaks from dents alone. Standing seam’s concealed clips and seamed edges give excellent wind performance. Screw-down’s wind resistance depends on the fastener pattern and the condition of the washers. Many Texas insurers apply a cosmetic damage exclusion to metal roofs of either type; read your policy.

Appearance

Standing seam’s clean vertical lines are the look associated with modern farmhouse and contemporary homes. Screw-down panels show the fastener grid and ribs, which suits agricultural and utilitarian buildings and some rustic homes. Both come in a wide range of factory-coated colors.

Walkability and penetrations

Standing seam needs care when walked on, and roof accessories such as solar mounts and snow guards clamp to the seams without penetrating. Screw-down panels are easier to walk on their ribs and simpler to cut around a vent, but every penetration is another exposed fastener and sealant joint.

Where each belongs

  • Primary residence you plan to keep: standing seam.
  • Home with a simple roofline and a budget closer to premium shingles: screw-down installed over solid decking and underlayment can be a good value, with a maintenance plan.
  • Barns, shops, carports, porch roofs: screw-down.
  • Roof with many valleys, dormers and penetrations: standing seam’s trim system handles complexity better, or consider architectural shingles.

Installing metal over an existing roof

Screw-down panels are sometimes installed over existing shingles on purlins. It saves tear-off but hides the deck and traps heat, and some cities and insurers have rules about it. Advantage recommends tearing off and installing over new underlayment on homes so the deck can be inspected and the roof can be warranted.

Repairs

Standing seam repairs are specialized, and matching a panel profile years later requires knowing the manufacturer. Screw-down repairs are simpler: replace screws, seal, swap a panel. Keep the panel manufacturer and color code in your records either way.

Get both quoted

Advantage Roofing Company installs metal roofing on homes and commercial buildings across Tyler, Longview and East Texas and will quote standing seam and screw-down side by side on your roof, along with an architectural shingle option for comparison. Call (903) 939-3168 or schedule a free estimate.

Residential

If you're building a home or office, trust Advantage Roofing with your shingle roof installation

Commercial

If your flat roof is leaking, don't take time out of your busy schedule to attempt a DIY repair job.

Storm Damage

When your property has weathered a storm, you can count on Advantage Roofing Company!

Gallery

Take a moment to view our past projects.