A denial letter is the insurer’s first answer, not necessarily its last. Roof claims in Texas get denied for reasons that are sometimes right, sometimes wrong, and often fixable with better documentation. The steps below are the ones that work for Tyler homeowners, in the order to take them.
Get the denial in writing and read it
Ask for the denial letter and the adjuster’s full report, including photos and the estimate if one was written. The letter must state the reason. The common ones:
- Damage is wear and tear, not storm damage.
- Damage is below the deductible.
- Damage predates the policy or a previous claim.
- Cosmetic damage excluded.
- The roof is covered at actual cash value and the payment is small, not zero.
- Late reporting.
Each reason has a different response, so you need to know which one you are dealing with.
Get an independent inspection
If you filed without a roofer’s inspection, get one now. If you had one, get the roofer back on the roof with the denial letter in hand. Advantage Roofing Company provides free storm inspections in Tyler, with chalked test squares, photos of every slope and every soft metal, and a written report. The question the report answers is specific: is there storm damage of the kind the policy covers, and does the evidence show it.
Hail leaves patterns. It hits the side of the roof facing the storm harder, it dents gutters and vents in proportion to its size, and the bruises are random, not in rows. Wear and tear is uniform and follows sun exposure. An adjuster who spent fifteen minutes on a roof can honestly miss what a thorough inspection finds.
Request a re-inspection
Call the claims department, reference the claim number, and request a re-inspection based on new documentation. Send the report and photos. Ask that your roofer be present. Many denials are reversed at this stage, especially when soft-metal damage establishes that hail of a damaging size hit the house.
Supplement a partial denial
If the insurer approved a repair but denied a replacement, or approved some slopes and not others, the response is a supplement: a line-item estimate with photos showing why the full scope is needed. Common grounds are that repairs cannot be made without damaging surrounding brittle shingles, that the shingle is discontinued and cannot be matched, or that code requires items the adjuster left off.
Invoke the appraisal clause
Most Texas homeowners policies include an appraisal provision for disputes over the amount of loss, not whether the loss is covered. Each side hires an appraiser, the two choose an umpire, and the decision is binding on the amount. There is a cost, and it only applies to the value of a covered claim, so it fits a lowballed scope better than a flat denial.
File a complaint with the Texas Department of Insurance
TDI accepts complaints against insurers and will ask the company to respond. It does not decide claims, but a complaint gets a supervisor’s attention and creates a record. Texas law also sets prompt-payment deadlines for insurers, and a complaint can prompt a review of whether they were met.
Consider a public adjuster or an attorney
A public adjuster is licensed to represent you in the claim for a percentage of the recovery. An attorney makes sense when the claim is large and the denial looks like bad faith. Either is a step to take after the inspection and re-inspection, not before, because good documentation is what they will need too.
Things that do not help
- Hiring a contractor who promises to “get the claim approved” by inflating it.
- Letting someone waive your deductible, which is illegal in Texas and taints the claim.
- Waiting. Deadlines for appraisal, complaints and legal action run from the date of denial.
Sometimes the denial is right
If the roof is simply old, a claim will not fix it. The honest options are a repair, a Shingle Rx treatment on a roof with life left, or a replacement paid directly or through financing. We will tell you which one applies.
Start with the roof
Whatever the denial says, the facts are on your roof. Advantage Roofing Company has worked East Texas storm claims since 2008. Call our Tyler office at (903) 939-3168 or schedule a free inspection.