Can You Put New Shingles Over Old Ones in Texas?

Building codes in Texas generally allow one layer of new shingles over one existing layer, and never a third. So it can be done. On most Tyler homes it should not be. A roof-over saves the tear-off cost on the day of the job and costs more over the life of the roof, in heat, hidden decking damage, warranty limits and insurance trouble. Advantage Roofing Company does full tear-offs for those reasons, and here is the detail behind the recommendation.

What a roof-over is

Also called a layover or a second layer. The old shingles stay in place; the roofer nails new shingles directly over them, sometimes after cutting back the old ridge and eave edges. Old flashing and pipe boots usually stay too. It is faster and skips the dumpster.

What the code says

The International Residential Code, which Texas cities including Tyler adopt with local amendments, limits a roof to two layers of asphalt shingles. It also prohibits a roof-over when the existing roof is water-soaked, deteriorated, or has a layer of wood shakes, slate or tile underneath, and it requires that the existing deck be sound. Some cities require a permit and inspection either way. Check with the city’s building department before assuming a layover is allowed on your house.

Why it is a poor fit for East Texas

Heat

Two layers of asphalt hold more heat than one. In a Tyler summer the top layer runs hotter and ages faster, because the layer underneath insulates it from the deck. Shingle manufacturers know this; some reduce or void their warranty on roof-overs.

Hidden decking

The main reason to tear off is to see the wood. A layover covers rot, delamination and loose decking that will keep deteriorating under the new roof. By the time it shows up as a sag or a leak, the fix is a full tear-off plus decking, with the new shingles thrown away.

Flashing and penetrations

New shingles over old flashing is the leak waiting to happen. Doing the flashing right in a layover means tearing out sections anyway, and most layover jobs skip it.

A rough surface

Old shingles that have curled or cupped telegraph through the new layer. The new roof looks wavy and the new shingles do not seal flat, which hurts wind resistance.

Weight

A second layer adds significant weight to the framing. Most homes can carry it, but older homes with undersized rafters or existing sag should not.

Insurance and resale

Many Texas insurers will not write a new policy on a roof with two layers, or will cover it at actual cash value only. When you sell, an inspector will note the layover and buyers will discount for the tear-off they will eventually pay for. And when the next hail storm hits, an adjuster’s scope for a two-layer roof involves arguments over which layer the damage is on and what the claim should pay for removing both.

When a layover is reasonable

  • A low-value outbuilding where appearance and longevity do not matter.
  • A single existing layer in good, flat condition on a simple roof, where the owner understands the trade-offs and the manufacturer’s warranty terms.
  • A short-term hold on a property that will be redeveloped.

What a full tear-off gets you

  • A deck you can see, with any bad sheets replaced and photographed.
  • New ice and water shield, underlayment, drip edge and flashing.
  • A flat, sealed shingle installation with the manufacturer’s full warranty.
  • A roof an insurer and a buyer will accept without question.

Tear-off adds labor and disposal to the estimate. On a Tyler home it is a modest share of the total, and Advantage offers financing if the difference matters this year.

The roof under your roof

If you are not sure how many layers your house has, look at the edge at the eave: a double thickness of shingles along the drip edge usually means two layers. Or let us look. Advantage Roofing Company inspects roofs in Tyler for free and gives you a written report. Call (903) 939-3168 or schedule online.

Residential

If you're building a home or office, trust Advantage Roofing with your shingle roof installation

Commercial

If your flat roof is leaking, don't take time out of your busy schedule to attempt a DIY repair job.

Storm Damage

When your property has weathered a storm, you can count on Advantage Roofing Company!

Gallery

Take a moment to view our past projects.