ACV vs. RCV: What Your Roof Insurance Policy Really Pays

Replacement cost value (RCV) pays to put a new roof on your house after a covered storm, minus your deductible. Actual cash value (ACV) pays the value of your old roof, which is the replacement cost minus depreciation for its age and condition. On a new roof the two are close. On a 15-year-old roof in Tyler, the difference can be most of the cost of the job. Many Texas homeowners do not know which one they have until a claim is paid.

How depreciation works on a roof

Insurers assign a shingle roof an expected life, often 20 to 30 years depending on the material, and depreciate it in a straight line. A roof halfway through its expected life is depreciated about 50 percent. Some policies depreciate on age alone; others let the adjuster factor in condition. Either way, the older the roof, the bigger the depreciation.

A worked example

Suppose a replacement is scoped at $20,000, the roof is 12 years old on a 25-year life, and the wind and hail deductible is $4,000.

  • Depreciation: 12 of 25 years is 48 percent, or $9,600.
  • Actual cash value: $20,000 minus $9,600 is $10,400.

Under an RCV policy: the first check is the ACV minus the deductible, $6,400. When the roof is finished and invoiced, the insurer releases the $9,600 of recoverable depreciation. You end up with $16,000, which is the replacement cost minus your deductible.

Under an ACV policy: you receive $6,400, and that is the end of the claim. The remaining $13,600 is yours to pay.

Those numbers are illustrative, not a quote for any Tyler roof, but the structure is exactly how claims are paid.

Why so many Texas roofs are now on ACV

After years of hail losses, many insurers moved roofs over a certain age to ACV, or added a roof payment schedule that does the same thing by a different name. This often happens at renewal through an endorsement that is easy to miss. If your roof is more than 10 years old, it is worth a call to your agent to confirm how it is covered.

How to tell which you have

  • Look at the declarations page for “roof surfacing,” “roof payment schedule,” “actual cash value roof,” or “replacement cost.”
  • Look for a separate wind and hail deductible stated as a percentage.
  • Ask your agent to put the answer in writing.

What this means when a storm hits

With RCV, the key is finishing the job and submitting the final invoice so the depreciation is released. Advantage sends the completion paperwork to your insurer as part of every claim job.

With ACV, you are choosing how to cover the gap. Options include a less expensive shingle line, financing the balance, or, if the roof is not actually failing, a repair or Shingle Rx treatment to buy time. We will walk through each option with real numbers from your roof.

What recoverable depreciation requires

On an RCV policy the second check is not automatic. The insurer releases it when the roof has actually been replaced, the final invoice and a completion certificate have been submitted, and the deductible has been paid. Policies set a deadline for this, often within a year of the loss. Homeowners who cash the first check and delay the roof past that date forfeit the depreciation, which on an older Tyler roof can be most of the money.

Can you switch to RCV?

Often, if the roof is in good condition and not too old, and sometimes only after a replacement. A new roof with Class 4 impact-resistant shingles can make it easier to get RCV coverage and a premium discount. Ask your agent what their underwriting requires; a roof inspection report from Advantage can support the request.

Get the numbers for your roof

Before the next hail season, know what your roof would be worth to your insurer. Advantage Roofing Company provides free inspections and written reports in Tyler and East Texas, and our team has worked storm claims since 2008. Call (903) 939-3168 or schedule online.

Residential

If you're building a home or office, trust Advantage Roofing with your shingle roof installation

Commercial

If your flat roof is leaking, don't take time out of your busy schedule to attempt a DIY repair job.

Storm Damage

When your property has weathered a storm, you can count on Advantage Roofing Company!

Gallery

Take a moment to view our past projects.