Synthetic underlayment is the better choice under a new shingle roof in East Texas, and it is what Advantage Roofing Company installs on replacements unless a customer specifically asks otherwise. Asphalt-saturated felt paper did the job for a century and still meets code, but it wrinkles in humidity, tears in wind, and degrades if the roof sits uncovered. Synthetic costs a little more per square and removes those problems. Here is the comparison, and where ice and water shield fits regardless.
What underlayment does
Underlayment is the water-resistant layer between the roof deck and the shingles. Shingles shed most of the water; underlayment catches what blows under them in wind-driven rain, backs up the flashing, and keeps the deck dry between tear-off and shingle installation. It is also required by code and by every shingle manufacturer’s warranty.
Felt (asphalt-saturated paper)
Traditional felt comes in two weights, No. 15 and No. 30. The heavier No. 30 is what most roofers used when felt was standard.
- Pros: inexpensive, familiar, meets code, and some roofers prefer its grip underfoot.
- Cons: absorbs moisture and wrinkles in East Texas humidity, which can telegraph through shingles; tears easily when walked on or in wind; dries out and cracks if left exposed to sun for more than a few days; heavy to carry up a ladder.
Synthetic underlayment
A woven or spun polypropylene or polyethylene sheet, often with a slip-resistant coating on top.
- Pros: does not absorb water or wrinkle; several times stronger against tearing; lightweight rolls cover more squares; can be left exposed for weeks or months per the manufacturer if weather interrupts the job; better footing for the crew on steep Tyler roofs.
- Cons: costs more than felt; must be fastened with cap nails or cap staples per the manufacturer, not plain staples; some products are slick when wet or dusty.
The exposure rating matters in storm season. If a surprise shower or a material delay leaves a roof dried-in but not shingled, synthetic holds; felt does not.
Ice and water shield is a different product
Both felt and synthetic are water-resistant, not waterproof: nails go through them. Ice and water shield is a self-adhering rubberized asphalt membrane that seals around every nail and bonds to the deck. It goes where water concentrates or backs up:
- In every valley.
- Around chimneys, skylights and all penetrations.
- Along eaves, especially on low-slope sections and where ice has formed in past winters.
- At wall intersections and under step flashing.
Advantage installs ice and water shield at these locations on every Tyler replacement, with synthetic underlayment over the rest of the deck. Some homeowners choose full-deck ice and water coverage on low-pitch roofs or roofs with a history of wind-driven leaks; it adds cost and is worth discussing.
How it affects your warranty
Shingle manufacturers’ enhanced system warranties, including the Owens Corning Platinum Preferred warranties Advantage can offer, require the manufacturer’s own underlayment and ice barrier products as part of the system. Using matched components is one of the conditions that gets you the longer coverage.
What to look for on an estimate
The underlayment should be named by brand and type, and the estimate should state where ice and water shield will be installed. “Felt” with no weight, or no mention of ice and water shield at all, is a sign of a bid built to be cheap rather than right.
Questions for your roofer
- Which underlayment, by name?
- Where does ice and water shield go on my roof?
- How long can the deck sit dried-in if weather interrupts?
- Does this combination qualify for the manufacturer’s system warranty?
Advantage Roofing Company will answer all four on a free estimate in Tyler. Call (903) 939-3168 or schedule online.