An insurance adjuster inspecting a Tyler roof after a storm is answering three questions: did a covered event damage the roof, how much of it, and what will it cost to put right. The visit usually takes under an hour, and the adjuster follows a fairly standard routine. Knowing it lets you prepare, and lets your roofer make sure nothing gets missed.
Before the roof: the ground walk
The adjuster starts at ground level, looking for collateral damage that confirms a storm hit the property: dented gutters and downspouts, dings in the AC condenser fins, splatter marks on the driveway, fence and siding, torn window screens, damaged mailboxes and grills. This evidence establishes hail size and direction and is hard to dispute. Photograph it yourself before anything is cleaned up or repaired.
The soft metals
On the roof, the first stop is everything metal: vents, pipe boots, flashing, ridge vent, turbines, gutters and drip edge. Hail dents metal in proportion to its size, and the dents show which direction the storm came from. Fresh dents are shiny inside; old ones are dull. Soft-metal damage is often the deciding evidence on a claim, because shingle bruises can be argued and dented metal cannot.
The test square
The adjuster marks a 10-foot by 10-foot square in chalk on each slope, usually on the slopes facing the storm first, and counts the hail hits inside it. Each hit is circled. Many insurers use a threshold of hits per square to decide between repair and replacement; a slope with a heavy count is replaced, a slope with a few hits may be scoped for repair. Counts are recorded per slope, which is why the whole roof needs to be looked at, not just the worst side.
What counts as a hit
A hail bruise is a round area where granules have been knocked loose and the mat underneath is fractured or soft to the touch. The adjuster will press on suspect spots. Random placement, varied size and consistency with the storm direction mark real hail. Uniform wear, blisters, scuffs from foot traffic and mechanical damage are not hail, and a good adjuster will separate them. So will a good roofer.
Wind damage
For wind, the adjuster looks for missing shingles, creased shingles that were lifted and laid back, and unsealed shingles that lift easily by hand. Creases are counted like hail hits.
The brittleness test
On older roofs the adjuster may lift a shingle to see whether it can be repaired. If the shingle cracks when lifted, repairs are impractical because every shingle disturbed would break, and that supports replacement rather than repair.
Other items on the list
- Age and condition of the roof, to estimate depreciation.
- Number of layers.
- Pitch and complexity, which affect the labor cost in the estimate.
- Skylights, satellite dishes and other items on the roof.
- Interior damage, if you report any; show them the ceiling stains.
What the adjuster writes
The result is an estimate, often produced in software that prices each item by line: tear-off, shingles by square, underlayment, drip edge, flashing, vents, gutters, and so on. It shows replacement cost, depreciation, your deductible and the actual cash value of the first payment. You receive a copy.
How to prepare
- Have a roofer’s inspection and report done first, so you know what should be found.
- Have your roofer attend. A roofer who has already chalked the hits walks the adjuster to them and points out the dented metals.
- Have your photos, the storm date, and any prior inspection reports handy.
- Do not repair or clean anything before the inspection.
- Do not let anyone pressure the adjuster or argue; documentation does the work.
If the scope misses something
Your roofer submits a supplement with photos and a line-item estimate. Insurers expect supplements, and missed items are usually added without dispute when they are documented.
Advantage at the inspection
Advantage Roofing Company attends adjuster inspections for Tyler homeowners as part of our storm claim assistance, and has since 2008. Call (903) 939-3168 or schedule a free pre-adjuster inspection.